When the weather cools off, it’s a great time to break out the slow-cooker. Make this delicious potato and cheddar soup for an easy dinner.
Jump to RecipeWhen the weather starts to cool down I love to pull out the slow-cooker and start making some delicious soups and chili recipes. I also love almost anything with potatoes, so decided I needed to try some potato soup recipes. Since cheese is also a favorite I made a potato and cheddar soup.
This recipe is mostly based on one of my favorite cookbooks, 100 Days of Real Food. We made just a few slight changes to make it to our tastes. We also realized that in the book she says it’s good to freeze. The soup does not reheat well for us. This is one to make with a larger group or make sure to eat leftovers within a day or two.
Since this is a slow-cooker recipe, it’s great for those busy weekday dinners. Get everything started in the morning. You will have a delicious dinner ready when you get home.

Step by Step
Start by chopping up the potatoes and onions. I usually cut the potatoes into pieces that are about 1 inch, and chop the onion very small. You don’t want to bite into a huge chunk of onion when eating the soup.

Place the potatoes, onion, garlic, and chicken broth into the slow cooker. Put on the lid and cook on low for 6-8 hours or high for 4 hours.

Use a potato masher to lightly mash up the potatoes. You don’t want to go overboard and make mashed potatoes in there. You want to crush the potatoes a little bit to release some of the starch into the soup. Add the butter and heavy cream. Use an immersion blender to combine.

Add the cheddar cheese in and stir until it has melted into the soup. Serve the soup warm and garnish with some freshly chopped green onions if desired.


Recipe
Originally Published On: October 29, 2017
Last Updated On: November 13, 2019

Easy Slow-Cooker Potato and Cheddar Soup
Ingredients
- 4 potatoes
- 1/2 cup onion (diced)
- 2 cloves garlic (minced)
- 4 cups chicken broth
- 2 tbsp butter
- 1/2 cup heavy cream
- 2 cups cheddar cheese (shredded)
- Toppings such as cheddar cheese, sour cream, bacon, sliced green onions
Recommended Equipment
Instructions
- Cut the potatoes into 1-inch cubes and place in a slow-cooker
- Add the onion, broth, and garlic
- Cook on high for 4 hours or low for 7 hours
- Add the butter and puree the soup with an immersion or hand blender
- Stir in the cream and cheddar cheese
- Serve the soup warm with desired toppings
All nutritional information is based on third-party calculations and should be considered estimates. Actual nutrition content will vary based on brands used, measuring methods, portion sizes, and more.
Can one use sweet potatoes instead of regular potatoes in this recipe?
Hmm…. I’ve never tried that because I personally don’t really care for sweet potatoes. I don’t know how the flavor of them would work with the other flavors, but if you think it would be good you could experiment!
My daughter loves this soup but oddly I have never made it for her. I am going to try your recipe and place myself in the running for mother of the year! 😉
It’s so easy! I hope she loves it!!
That’s really awesome! I’ve always liked the combination of cheese and potatoes! Not to mention that cooking this using a slow cooker makes things easier!
Me too! Potatoes are my weakness, add cheese and I’m sold! We love using the slow cooker for easy meals.
My family loves potato cheddar soup! I need to try this recipe so we can have it from the comfort of our home and I can make it anytime.
It’s so easy to make, I’m sure you will all enjoy it!
OMG this recipe couldn’t come at a more perfect time. Been meaning to try a potatoes soup. Was thinking of making a Toscana soup but this looks really neat too.
Glad I could help 😊 I hope you get a chance to try it and enjoy!
Wow this looks amazing!! This is exactly what I need with the colder weather happening!! I wonder If I could make Broccoli cheddar a similar way? xo
The weather warmed back up here, but once it cools off we are making this again! I haven’t tried a broccoli cheddar soup, but now you have me curious.
I would LOVE this cheddar potato soup for dinner tonight! I love soup, ALL soup, esp this time of year. Soup for the soul ; )
Soup is so good! It got hot here in Texas again, but we are making this once it cools down here as well!
Alright! I️ want it to get cold so I️ can make this immediately. It looks so good!!
I know. I got everything to make it again soon and then it got hot again!
This looks so yummy, and so fall! I love it, can’t wait to make it!
Yes, soups are so great for the cooler weather of fall!
yessss give me all the delicious soups especially during winter!!! I will give this one a shot, can’t wait.
I agree, the soups are perfect when it’s cold outside!
We just got an insta-pot so…. Let’s DO THIS! hahaha! I think my husband would love this because he LOVES potatoes and he loves cheese !!
I’ve never tried it in the insta-pot since I don’t have one, but I would love to know how it comes out!
You had me at easy and slowcooker which are the only ways I cook right now! This soup sounds AMAZING!
I love love love using the slow cooker during the winter! There are so many delicious warm meals you can easily make in them.
I am on a slow cooker kick right now- especially soups! Potato soup is one of my favorites so I’m excited to try your recipe!
The slow cooker is perfect for the cool weather months. I hope you enjoy my take on potato soup, too 🙂
This would be perfect for this beautiful fall night. I might try to make this tomorrow night. Thanks for sharing another wonderful recipe.
My family in South Florida have said they are finally getting some cooler weather. I hope you are enjoying it and make this delicious soup to keep warm.
Easy Slow-Cooker Potato and Cheddar Soup dish looks so delicious. Thank you for sharing it. It is a great dish to make when my family comes over for dinner on the weekends.
This would be great for having people over. It’s easy to put together and makes a good amount to share.
This is so perfect for this season! I love potatoes and cheese, so it’s definitely something I will have to try soon 😍 Love your simple recipes ❤
Potatoes and cheese are two of my favorite foods, too!
I love the idea of using an immersion blender for this, great way to mix things up. I so need to find a small crockpot!
I’ve only used my immersion blender for a few recipes, but it works so well! I wasn’t sure how it would do with the chunks of potato but they were soft enough to blend with no problems.
This sounds really tasty, and looks even tastier! And I LOVE slow-cooker recipes – SO easy! 🙂
Slow cooker recipes are the best, especially in the cooler months!
Definitely soup season now. Yep love me some potato soup. I prefer potato and leek to potato and cheese though.
You know, I’ve only tried leeks in one or two recipes. Never with potatoes, though, I’ll have to try that next time.