Quick and Easy Homemade Pizza Bagels Recipe

This easy homemade pizza bagels recipe shows you how to make crispy, cheesy homemade pizza bagels in the oven, air fryer, or toaster oven.

Jump to Recipe

I am a sucker for some good cheesy pizza! I craved pizza so badly when I was pregnant with Tyler. Pizza was about the only craving I really had. And nothing could beat it. To keep the costs down, I started making homemade pizza bagels at least once a week. 

I have always enjoyed pizza, though. When I was in high school, Friday night was pizza night. We always ordered our Papa John’s pizza and a Coke. My best friend knew it. She was over most Friday nights and everyone knew that was pizza night in the Beller household!

Ordering pizza can get costly, though, so I have found a way to make my own personal pizza whenever I want it for lunch or dinner or a late-night snack. Besides, have you ever checked the ingredients and nutrition facts for frozen mini pizza bagels? I much prefer to make them at home so I can use decent ingredients. And when it only takes a few minutes, there’s no reason not to.

Topping Suggestions

Some of the toppings we have tried on pizza or pizza bagels include:

• ​Mozzarella Cheese
• Ricotta Cheese
• Cheddar Cheese
• Parmesan Cheese
• Pepperoni Slices
• Mini Pepperonis
• Turkey Pepperoni
• Ground Beef
• Italian Sausage
• Bell Peppers
• Onion
• Black Olives
• Mushrooms
• Pizza Sauce
• Marinara Sauce
• Garlic Powder
• Italian Seasoning
• Red Pepper Flakes

The best part of this recipe is being able to customize it to exactly what you want. I like cheese only and I like ricotta cheese along with mozzarella. Justin doesn’t like ricotta but always wants pepperoni on his. Tyler and Ryan can never make up their minds if they prefer cheese only or pepperoni, so we have to ask every time. That’s also why we make regular homemade pizza most of the time, too. 

Actually, Justin was the one who made homemade pizza bagels one night when we were in college. I don’t know why I hadn’t ever thought of it before. I love bagels. In our family my grandma was known as the “bagel queen” and I was the “bagel princess”. You can almost always find a package of bagels in my pantry at any given time.

I’ve only ever made this recipe with plain bagels, but I’m sure you could also try it with some of the flavored bagels as well. I don’t think blueberry would be very good for it, but everything bagels might be if you like those ones. I always buy Thomas brand bagels, but that’s just a personal preference since it’s what I grew up eating. And if you want small ones for the kids, you could also buy mini bagels and make those as well.

Ingredient Notes

Use sturdy, full-sized plain or everything bagels for the chewiest, most pizza-like bite. Slice evenly and use a light hand with sauce to keep the crumb from getting soggy. Low-moisture, part-skim mozzarella shreds melt cleanly; blend in a little provolone for extra pull. Pat watery toppings like mushrooms, pineapple, or fresh mozzarella dry before adding. If using pepperoni, mini slices nestle into the hole and crisp nicely, but quartered regular slices work just as well.

Oven-Baked Method

For classic, bubbly cheese and crisp edges, bake at 400°F on a parchment-lined sheet pan. Spread about one tablespoon of sauce on each bagel half, top with one ounce of cheese, and add toppings. Bake for 8–12 minutes until the cheese is melted and the edges are golden. For extra color, move the pan to the top rack for the last minute. Let cool for two minutes before serving so the cheese sets and slices don’t slide.

Air Fryer Method

Air fry at 360°F for 4–6 minutes, checking at the four-minute mark. Build the bagels directly on the air fryer tray or in a parchment-lined basket with perforations. If your unit runs hot, preheat and cook at 350°F to prevent overly browned cheese. Work in batches to avoid crowding so air can circulate and crisp the edges.

Toaster Oven Method

Toast plain bagel halves for one to two minutes to dry the surface, then top and bake at 400°F for 6–8 minutes. This quick pre-toast helps resist sogginess and keeps the crumb pleasantly chewy.

Mini Pizza Bagels

Mini bagels are perfect for lunchboxes, after-school snacks, or party platters. Use a teaspoon of sauce and a heaping tablespoon of cheese per half. Bake at 400°F for 6–8 minutes or air fry at 360°F for 3–5 minutes. Offer a few mini toppings like diced peppers, quartered pepperoni, or crumbled sausage so each bite has balanced flavor.

Make-Ahead and Freezer Prep

Assemble bagel halves up to 24 hours in advance, then cover and refrigerate. For longer storage, freeze assembled, unbaked bagels in a single layer on a sheet pan until firm, then transfer to a freezer bag for up to two months. Bake from frozen at 400°F for 12–15 minutes or air fry at 350°F for 6–8 minutes. To prevent ice crystals, blot sauce and toppings dry before assembly and avoid fresh tomatoes unless well-seeded.

Topping Ideas by Category

Keep flavors balanced by pairing one to two proteins with one to two vegetables and a finish. Try pepperoni or Italian sausage with mushrooms and black olives; diced ham with pineapple and green onion; shredded rotisserie chicken with barbecue sauce and pickled red onions; sautéed spinach with artichokes and a sprinkle of parmesan; or pesto with roasted red peppers and sun-dried tomatoes. Finish hot bagels with torn basil, red pepper flakes, or a drizzle of garlic oil.

Flavor Variations

Swap red sauce for pesto, Alfredo, or garlic butter for white pizza vibes. Go Margherita with a thin layer of sauce, fresh mozzarella slices patted dry, and basil added after baking. For the supreme pizza layer sauce, mozzarella, cooked sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, and olives. For mushroom lovers, sauté mushrooms with a pinch of salt to release moisture, then pile on with fontina for a luxe melt.

Preventing Soggy Bagels

Lightly toast or par-bake the cut sides before saucing. Use a thin layer of sauce, pat all toppings dry, and place cheese over the sauce to create a moisture barrier. Load dense or wet toppings sparingly and keep pieces small so they heat through without steaming the bagel.

Dietary Swaps

Choose gluten-free bagels if needed and bake on parchment for easy release. Use lactose-free or dairy-free mozzarella-style shreds and finish with olive oil for shine. For a lighter option, use thin-sliced bagels, reduce cheese by half, and pile on roasted vegetables. Turkey pepperoni and chicken sausage deliver flavor with less fat and salt.

Kid Helper Steps

Set up a topping station with bowls and small spoons. Let kids spread sauce, sprinkle cheese, and choose two toppings. Offer mini bagels for smaller hands and bake on the center rack for even browning. Cool for a couple of minutes and serve with carrot sticks or apple slices for an easy, balanced meal.

Serving Suggestions

Serve pizza bagels with a simple green salad, Caesar salad, or garlic-roasted broccoli. For game day, offer a trio of sauces—marinara, pesto, and BBQ—plus bowls of toppings so guests can build their own. Add a side of warm marinara for dipping and a finishing sprinkle of grated parmesan at the table.

Pizza Bagel Bar for Parties

Lay out halved bagels, sauces, cheeses, proteins, and vegetables in that order so assembly flows quickly. Label toppings and include a few unexpected options like pickled jalapeños, banana peppers, caramelized onions, or hot honey. Bake trays by topping type to streamline timing, and place finished bagels on a wire rack so bottoms stay crisp.

Troubleshooting

If the cheese over-browns before the bagel is hot, lower the rack position or reduce the temperature by 25°F and extend the cook time by a minute or two. For toppings that slide, let baked bagels rest for two minutes. If the bottom is too soft, bake on a preheated sheet pan or pizza steel to crisp the cut sides.

Easy Garlic Butter Upgrade

Brush cut sides with a quick garlic butter made from melted butter, minced garlic or garlic powder, and a pinch of Italian seasoning before adding sauce. This creates a flavorful barrier that keeps the crumb crisp and adds a pizzeria aroma.

Seasonality and Fresh Add-Ons

In summer, finish with torn basil, cherry tomatoes that have been halved and seeded, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze. In the fall, add sautéed mushrooms and caramelized onions. For the winter, use jarred roasted red peppers and olives. In spring, try asparagus tips and a squeeze of lemon over a pesto base.

Homemade Pizza Bagel FAQ

Homemade Pizza Bagels Step by Step

Ingredients

• 2 bagels
• 4 tbsp pizza sauce (or marinara sauce)
• 1/2 cup mozzarella cheese (shredded)
• 2 tbsp each pizza toppings desired

Preparation

Pizza Bagels are fairly simple to make. Start by lining your baking pan with foil. Of course, you don’t have to do this, but it makes for a much quicker cleanup when you are done. Or you can use a silicone baking sheet since those still clean easily and don’t waste the aluminum foil.

Lay your bagels open on the baking sheet and start to build your pizza by adding the sauce to each bagel half. Tip: If you are using ricotta cheese, it’s easier to spread that before the sauce so it can stick to the bagel better.

Top the sauce with mozzarella cheese and any other desired toppings such as pepperoni, black olives, mushrooms, extra cheese, etc. Anything that would be good on a regular pizza will be good on these bagels as well.

Set your oven’s broiler to low and cook the pizza bagel halves under the heat for about 5-7 minutes. You want the cheese to melt and start to brown but not get too cooked. This will also warm the bagels a bit and the sauce. Remove from the oven and serve while they are warm!

Pizza Bagels Leftovers

Storage: Store leftover pizza bagels in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 days.

Reheating: The best way to reheat pizza bagels is in the oven, toaster oven, or air fryer. If you microwave them, the bagels tend to get soft and chewy.

Freezing: If you want to freeze leftovers, lay them in a single layer on a rimmed baking sheet. Once frozen, move to a freezer bag. They should last for up to 2 months in the freezer.

Pizza Bagel Recipe

Homemade Pizza Bagels

This easy homemade pizza bagels recipe shows you how to make crispy, cheesy homemade pizza bagels in the oven, air fryer, or toaster oven.

Prep Time 5 minutes minutes

Cook Time 5 minutes minutes

Total Time 10 minutes minutes

Course:

Main Dish

Cuisine:

American

|

Italian

Keyword:

bagel

|

cheese

|

sauce

Servings: 2 pizza bagels

5 from 4 votes

Ingredients

• 2 bagels
• 4 tbsp pizza sauce
• 1/2 cup mozzarella cheese (shredded)
• 2 tbsp each pizza toppings desired

Recommended Equipment

• Baking Sheet
• Aluminum Foil
• Box Grater

Instructions

• Line pan with foil for easy cleanup
• Add sauce to the bagels
• Add cheese and toppings on the bagels
• Broil on low for 5-7 minutes or until cheese starts to brown

Click the buttons below to share and print this recipe

Pin Recipe Print Recipe

Nutrition Facts

Homemade Pizza Bagels

Amount Per Serving (1 each)

Calories 379 Calories from Fat 63

% Daily Value*

Fat 7g11%

Saturated Fat 3g15%

Cholesterol 22mg7%

Sodium 893mg37%

Potassium 226mg6%

Carbohydrates 58g19%

Fiber 2g8%

Sugar 1g1%

Protein 17g34%

Vitamin A 320IU6%

Vitamin C 2.1mg3%

Calcium 160mg16%

Iron 1.9mg11%

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

All nutritional information is based on third-party calculations and should be considered estimates. Actual nutrition content will vary based on brands used, measuring methods, portion sizes, and more.

Pizza Recipes

• Pizza Breadsticks
• Taco Pizza
• Stromboli
• Pizza Hot Pocket
• Pizza Burgers: The Perfect Combination of Two Favorites
• Homemade Pizza with a Bread Machine
• Super Easy Pizza Flatbread
• Pizza Dip
• Pizza Bagels

Ricotta Cheese

• Four Cheese Spinach Pasta
• Classic Stuffed Shells
• Lasagna Soup
• Homemade Pierogi
• Cheesy Chicken and Spinach Stromboli Ring
• Baked Ziti

Mozzarella Cheese

• Super Easy Homemade Fried Mozzarella Sticks Recipe
• Fresh Mozzarella-Topped (Not So) Flatbread
• Crispy Fried Mozzarella Cakes Recipe with Fresh Cheese
• Mozzarella-Stuffed Meatloaf
• Super Easy Pizza Dip
• Cheesy Meatball Skillet
• Homemade Pizza Burgers: The Best Combo of Two Recipes
• Five Cheese Pull-Apart Bread
• Chicken and Spinach Alfredo Bake Casserole
• Thai Basil Pesto Flatbread
• Easy Chicken Cordon Bleu
• Super Easy Pizza Flatbread
• Spinach and Artichoke Stuffed Shells
• Fresh Caprese Salad
• Spinach and Artichoke Quesadillas
• Easy Chicken Parmesan
• Kreacher’s French Onion Soup
• Hearty Sausage and Kale Pesto Pizza
• Classic Stuffed Shells
• Quick and Easy Homemade Pizza Bagels Recipe
• Baked Spinach Artichoke Dip
• Chicken and Spinach Casserole with Cream Cheese
• Baked Ziti
• BBQ Chicken Melt with Only 5 Ingredients
• Cheesy Garlic Bread
• Stromboli
• Cheesy Baked Crab Casserole
• Pizza Hot Pocket
• Cheesy Chicken and Spinach Stromboli Ring
• Hawaiian Chicken Wraps
• Cheesy Caper-Stuffed Tomatoes